October 2020 - Public - talk.mikrotik.com.au

State of 3G/4G fallback on MikroTik?
by Karl Auer 01 Sep '21

01 Sep '21

We need to quote to a client for two routers capable of running a VPN between two sites - easy, that's a MikroTik. But they want a fallback to 3G/4G so that the site that falls back keeps Internet access AND so that the VPN keeps running. What's the state of MikroTik 3G/4G fallback? Last I looked it seemed very roll-your-own, and supported only a few very specific dongles... Ideally it would work like the (vastly more expensive) Merakis and just fail everything over to the secondary link if the primary fails, where "fail" would be either a ping test or interface down. That said, I'm OK with a solution that needs more work, as long as once done it is set-and-forget. Any pointers? Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 Old fingerprint: 8454 EE43 6215 B6DD 1B4D 9D8D 984D 7BA1 7378 A38D

7 12

Axiom Cyber Shield
by Philip Loenneker 27 Jan '21

27 Jan '21

Hi all, After seeing their presentation at the Melbourne MUM, we've been having a look at Axiom Cyber Shield. Is anyone on here using it and happy to provide some feedback, on-list or off-list? It certainly sounds like a good product, but I only seem to be able to find sales pitch information, not unbiased reviews. Regards, Philip Loenneker | Network Engineer | TasmaNet 40-50 Innovation Drive, Dowsing Point, Tas 7010, Australia P: 1300 792 711 philip.loenneker(a)tasmanet.com.au<mailto:philip.loenneker@tasmanet.com.au> www.tasmanet.com.au<http://www.tasmanet.com.au/>

3 7

G.fast modem demand in AU?
by Mike Everest 27 Oct '20

27 Oct '20

Hi Folks! As many of you will be aware, the Proscend PS180-T SFP module modem seems to offer a serviceable means to add VDSL interface to MikroTik and other devices and reports suggest that performance is acceptable on most cases. Proscend have recently released a G.fast version (PS190-T - https://shop.duxtel.com.pdf/DM-190-T- G.fast-SFP-Modem-051011.pdf) and we are considering whether it is worth going down the tangled path of AU compliance certification for that one too... :-} I understand that NBNCo are in process of roll-out of G.fast in FTTC networks, but there is scant information as to whether they intend to supply the CPE side of the link also... I'm interested to hear any feedback/comments/suggestions on whether you think that there might be any value in bringing the new modem to the AU market? Thanks for any responses! (even criticisms! ;) Cheers, Mike.

4 3

iBGP over OSPF
by Philip Loenneker 23 Oct '20

23 Oct '20

Hi all, I have multiple MikroTik routers connected to non-MikroTik switches with OSPFv2 and v3 enabled on routers and switches (isolated VRF) to distribute loopbacks and interconnect subnets. No other subnets are in the IGP. I can establish iBGP peers between loopbacks and exchange all routes (showing recursive next hop), including default route, but I can't connect to subnets behind other routers. In a traceroute the switches report that there is no valid next hop. This all seems logical, except that all the guides say to do it this way. I've seen some guides say to run MPLS over the top to get reachability, but I don't want to have that, especially since some routers are CHR and have issues with MPLS on some hypervisors. Does anyone have any advice on this? Do I need to have L2 as adjacency between all routers eg with a tunnel over the OSPF loopbacks, or MPLS, or should this work as the guides all suggest? I'm sure I'm missing something obvious... Regards, Philip

3 5

Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question
by Karl Auer 17 Oct '20

17 Oct '20

On Sat, 2020-10-17 at 11:35 +1100, Stephen Schwetz wrote: > You can definately place the Telstra router behind a mikrotiks. If > you are lucky they will have an area if they have more then 2 lines. > You can request to have the lines on the router moved to the ata and > then you don't have to worry about it anymore > I'm sorry, I understood literally none of that. Why would I put the Telstra router *behind* a Mikrotik? What "area" do you mean? What are "the lines on the router". What is an "ata"? I've decided not to bother with Telstra routers any more. They will be discarded and replaced with devices that behave rationally and predictably. In my work with these Telstra routers I've also found them to be amazingly slow to boot, with absolutely hopeless (and extremely limited) user interfaces. In the particular case at hand, the client has decided not to bother with a VPN at all, and instead move their entire dataset to Dropbox! Not my idea :-) Thank you to all those who helped, I certainly learned a lot. And the upshot basically has been to drive me further into the arms of Mikrotik :-) Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556

1 0

[OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question
by Karl Auer 17 Oct '20

17 Oct '20

This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and connections from outside work flawlessly. When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering recommending... Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556

6 11

[OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question
by Service 16 Oct '20

16 Oct '20

I have had a similar issue and a registry tweak fixed it on a win7/8/10 machine. Try add these; [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\PolicyAgent] "AssumeUDPEncapsulationContextOnSendRule"=dword:00000002 [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\PolicyAgent\Parameters ] "AssumeUDPEncapsulationContextOnSendRule"=dword:00000002 Something about going from a nat to nat network I recall. I have used those Telstra Business Modem/Routers before and can confirm DMZ'ding the Mik or portforwarding to the Mik work with SSTP/L2TP/IKEv2 VPN. They must have the latest firmware though as there is a bug with the NAT settings I recall that switches between strict and loose? modes. A simple toggle from one back to the other fixed it for me on one job with older firmware. Also I only ever have to allow udp 500,4500 and 1701 with a ipsec policy:in rule to be more secure on the Mik. I only ever port forward udp 500 and 4500 on the Telstra modems and not 1701. Kind Regards, Kym Weckert Service Technician Allneeds Computers 342 King William Street Adelaide SA 5000 Ph: 08 8211 8661 | Web: allneeds.com.au Sales: sales(a)allneeds.com.au Tech Support service(a)allneeds.com.au Warranty & Returns warranty(a)allneeds.com.au Mon-Fri 9:30-5:30 | Sat 9:30-2:00 | Public Holidays, please visit website. ABN: 57 511 389 752 This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you have received this email in error please notify the system manager. This message contains confidential information and is intended only for the individual named. If you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this e-mail. Please notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this e-mail by mistake and delete this e-mail from your system. If you are not the intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. WARNING: Computer viruses can be transmitted via email. The recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. E-mail transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, or contain viruses. The sender therefore does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of e-mail transmission. -----Original Message----- From: Public <public-bounces(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> On Behalf Of public-request(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Sent: Friday, 16 October 2020 2:38 PM To: public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Subject: Public Digest, Vol 79, Issue 1 Send Public mailing list submissions to public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com.au or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to public-request(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au You can reach the person managing the list at public-owner(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific than "Re: Contents of Public digest..." Today's Topics: 1. [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Karl Auer) 2. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Aaron Were) 3. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Dave Browning) 4. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Mike Everest) 5. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Roger Plant) 6. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Roger Plant) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Message: 1 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:44:31 +1100 From: Karl Auer <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <d2f110cc4f2fecc3647d8bb723b4be627133e64d.camel(a)nullarbor.com.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and connections from outside work flawlessly. When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering recommending... Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 ------------------------------ Message: 2 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 13:00:00 +1100 From: Aaron Were <awere(a)tdj.com.au> To: kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au, MikroTik Australia Public List <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <CAAB_-AyHKxDF3hQv67hmOAoVJe_J-u8iF1qa_eFpbb=WKJj+Ag(a)mail.gmail.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" Yup, it's a Telstra thing. They sell am l2tp service so practically block any others. Your account manager might be able to help you, or just use wireguard/OpenVPN etc. On Fri, 16 Oct 2020, 12:47 Karl Auer, <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> wrote: > This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots > of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... > > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside work flawlessly. > > When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the > exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied > router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The > client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. > > Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network > works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS > user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside > the network and - nope. > > Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical > one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of > other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor > TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! > > Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to > it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously > considering recommending... > > Regards, K. > > -- > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 > http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 > > GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old > fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 > > > > _______________________________________________ > Public mailing list > Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au > http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. > au > ------------------------------ Message: 3 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:17:10 +1000 From: Dave Browning <dave(a)dlbnetworks.com> To: public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <9eaeeb3d-75d3-e19c-c446-26a8d911c1b2(a)dlbnetworks.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed Out of curiosity, why don't you just land the L2TP on the 'tik? On 16/10/2020 11:44 am, Karl Auer wrote > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside work flawlessly. ------------------------------ Message: 4 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 14:09:24 +1100 From: "Mike Everest" <mike(a)duxtel.com> To: <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au>, "'MikroTik Australia Public List'" <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <038601d6a369$c0b66200$42232600$(a)duxtel.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" L2TP is a GRE protocol, so there are limitations in supporting independent sessions through NAT (GRE has no 'ports' so NAT can't work the same way) Since Telstra operate their own L2TP services, I expect that they are likely to have some kind of regime in place that ensures robust provision of that solution which would need to intercept GRE traffic and inspect/direct accordingly. So I suppose it's just as likely that 'blocking' other third party l2tp is probably more of a 'collateral damage' of that system than intentional commercial protection :-j Cheers! Mike. > -----Original Message----- > From: Public [mailto:public-bounces@talk.mikrotik.com.au] On Behalf Of Karl > Auer > Sent: Friday, 16 October 2020 12:45 PM > To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> > Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question > > This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots > of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... > > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside > work flawlessly. > > When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the > exact same > way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just > doesn't work. > I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation > failed. > > Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network > works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS > user credentials > are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. > > Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical > one with the > big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one > a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can > tell they > don't work either! > > Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of > replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering > recommending... > > Regards, K. > > -- > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > ~~~~~~~~~~~ > Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 > http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 > > GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old > fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 > > > > _______________________________________________ > Public mailing list > Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au > http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. > au ------------------------------ Message: 5 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 15:03:25 +1100 From: "Roger Plant" <rplant(a)melbpc.org.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au>, kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <5F891B8D.10053.13E545E(a)rplant.melbpc.org.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Hi, A couple of thoughts. If the router is the telstra business router netgear v7610 (which it sounds very much like), various software versions of this have lots of problems with port forwarding. Telstra support know all about it, and you (or the registered owner) can ask them to downgrade it. (usually they downgrade to version 6A) 2.2.2.6A Note: I have not actually used the specific ports 500 and 4500, but have had to have a few downgraded for other port forwardings. You shouldn't port forward 1701, this traffic goes encrypted inside the ipsec on port 4500 (when natted as in this case). (or in the ESP payload when there is no Nat). Good Luck. Regards Roger From: Karl Auer <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Date sent: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:44:31 +1100 Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Send reply to: kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au, MikroTik Australia Public List <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> [ Double-click this line for list subscription options ] This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and connections from outside work flawlessly. When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering recommending... Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 _______________________________________________ Public mailing list Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. au---------------------------- Roger Plant ------------------------------ Message: 6 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 15:07:28 +1100 From: "Roger Plant" <rplant(a)melbpc.org.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au>, kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <5F891C80.12862.1420A81(a)rplant.melbpc.org.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII One other thought, Rebooting the Telstra Router after changing the port forwarding is sometimes required. ---------------------------- Roger Plant ------------------------------ Subject: Digest Footer _______________________________________________ Public mailing list Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com.au ------------------------------ End of Public Digest, Vol 79, Issue 1 *************************************

1 0

Re: [MT-AU Public] Public Digest, Vol 79, Issue 1
by Service 16 Oct '20

16 Oct '20

I have had a similar issue and a registry tweak fixed it on a win7/8/10 machine. Try add these; [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\PolicyAgent] "AssumeUDPEncapsulationContextOnSendRule"=dword:00000002 [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\PolicyAgent\Parameters ] "AssumeUDPEncapsulationContextOnSendRule"=dword:00000002 Something about going from a nat to nat network I recall. I have used those Telstra Business Modem/Routers before and can confirm DMZ'ding the Mik or portforwarding to the Mik work with SSTP/L2TP/IKEv2 VPN. They must have the latest firmware though as there is a bug with the NAT settings I recall that switches between strict and loose? modes. A simple toggle from one back to the other fixed it for me on one job with older firmware. Also I only ever have to allow udp 500,4500 and 1701 with a ipsec policy:in rule to be more secure on the Mik. I only ever port forward udp 500 and 4500 on the Telstra modems and not 1701. Kind Regards, Kym Weckert Service Technician Allneeds Computers 342 King William Street Adelaide SA 5000 Ph: 08 8211 8661 | Web: allneeds.com.au Sales: sales(a)allneeds.com.au Tech Support service(a)allneeds.com.au Warranty & Returns warranty(a)allneeds.com.au Mon-Fri 9:30-5:30 | Sat 9:30-2:00 | Public Holidays, please visit website. ABN: 57 511 389 752 This email and any files transmitted with it are confidential and intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom they are addressed. If you have received this email in error please notify the system manager. This message contains confidential information and is intended only for the individual named. If you are not the named addressee you should not disseminate, distribute or copy this e-mail. Please notify the sender immediately by e-mail if you have received this e-mail by mistake and delete this e-mail from your system. If you are not the intended recipient you are notified that disclosing, copying, distributing or taking any action in reliance on the contents of this information is strictly prohibited. WARNING: Computer viruses can be transmitted via email. The recipient should check this email and any attachments for the presence of viruses. The company accepts no liability for any damage caused by any virus transmitted by this email. E-mail transmission cannot be guaranteed to be secure or error-free as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, or contain viruses. The sender therefore does not accept liability for any errors or omissions in the contents of this message, which arise as a result of e-mail transmission. -----Original Message----- From: Public <public-bounces(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> On Behalf Of public-request(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Sent: Friday, 16 October 2020 2:38 PM To: public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Subject: Public Digest, Vol 79, Issue 1 Send Public mailing list submissions to public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au To subscribe or unsubscribe via the World Wide Web, visit http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com.au or, via email, send a message with subject or body 'help' to public-request(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au You can reach the person managing the list at public-owner(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au When replying, please edit your Subject line so it is more specific than "Re: Contents of Public digest..." Today's Topics: 1. [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Karl Auer) 2. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Aaron Were) 3. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Dave Browning) 4. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Mike Everest) 5. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Roger Plant) 6. Re: [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question (Roger Plant) ---------------------------------------------------------------------- Message: 1 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:44:31 +1100 From: Karl Auer <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <d2f110cc4f2fecc3647d8bb723b4be627133e64d.camel(a)nullarbor.com.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and connections from outside work flawlessly. When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering recommending... Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 ------------------------------ Message: 2 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 13:00:00 +1100 From: Aaron Were <awere(a)tdj.com.au> To: kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au, MikroTik Australia Public List <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <CAAB_-AyHKxDF3hQv67hmOAoVJe_J-u8iF1qa_eFpbb=WKJj+Ag(a)mail.gmail.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="UTF-8" Yup, it's a Telstra thing. They sell am l2tp service so practically block any others. Your account manager might be able to help you, or just use wireguard/OpenVPN etc. On Fri, 16 Oct 2020, 12:47 Karl Auer, <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> wrote: > This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots > of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... > > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside work flawlessly. > > When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the > exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied > router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The > client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. > > Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network > works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS > user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside > the network and - nope. > > Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical > one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of > other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor > TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! > > Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to > it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously > considering recommending... > > Regards, K. > > -- > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 > http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 > > GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old > fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 > > > > _______________________________________________ > Public mailing list > Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au > http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. > au > ------------------------------ Message: 3 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:17:10 +1000 From: Dave Browning <dave(a)dlbnetworks.com> To: public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <9eaeeb3d-75d3-e19c-c446-26a8d911c1b2(a)dlbnetworks.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=utf-8; format=flowed Out of curiosity, why don't you just land the L2TP on the 'tik? On 16/10/2020 11:44 am, Karl Auer wrote > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside work flawlessly. ------------------------------ Message: 4 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 14:09:24 +1100 From: "Mike Everest" <mike(a)duxtel.com> To: <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au>, "'MikroTik Australia Public List'" <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <038601d6a369$c0b66200$42232600$(a)duxtel.com> Content-Type: text/plain; charset="us-ascii" L2TP is a GRE protocol, so there are limitations in supporting independent sessions through NAT (GRE has no 'ports' so NAT can't work the same way) Since Telstra operate their own L2TP services, I expect that they are likely to have some kind of regime in place that ensures robust provision of that solution which would need to intercept GRE traffic and inspect/direct accordingly. So I suppose it's just as likely that 'blocking' other third party l2tp is probably more of a 'collateral damage' of that system than intentional commercial protection :-j Cheers! Mike. > -----Original Message----- > From: Public [mailto:public-bounces@talk.mikrotik.com.au] On Behalf Of Karl > Auer > Sent: Friday, 16 October 2020 12:45 PM > To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> > Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question > > This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots > of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... > > I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology > NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have > forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and > connections from outside > work flawlessly. > > When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the > exact same > way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just > doesn't work. > I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation > failed. > > Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network > works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS > user credentials > are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. > > Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical > one with the > big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one > a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can > tell they > don't work either! > > Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of > replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering > recommending... > > Regards, K. > > -- > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > ~~~~~~~~~~~ > Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 > http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 > > GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old > fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 > > > > _______________________________________________ > Public mailing list > Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au > http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. > au ------------------------------ Message: 5 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 15:03:25 +1100 From: "Roger Plant" <rplant(a)melbpc.org.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au>, kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <5F891B8D.10053.13E545E(a)rplant.melbpc.org.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII Hi, A couple of thoughts. If the router is the telstra business router netgear v7610 (which it sounds very much like), various software versions of this have lots of problems with port forwarding. Telstra support know all about it, and you (or the registered owner) can ask them to downgrade it. (usually they downgrade to version 6A) 2.2.2.6A Note: I have not actually used the specific ports 500 and 4500, but have had to have a few downgraded for other port forwardings. You shouldn't port forward 1701, this traffic goes encrypted inside the ipsec on port 4500 (when natted as in this case). (or in the ESP payload when there is no Nat). Good Luck. Regards Roger From: Karl Auer <kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> Date sent: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 12:44:31 +1100 Subject: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Send reply to: kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au, MikroTik Australia Public List <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au> [ Double-click this line for list subscription options ] This is not really a Mikrotik question, but the people here have lots of experience with routers generally so I will ask anyway... I (of course) use a Mikrotik router at home. I also have a Synology NAS at home, which supports an LT2P/IPsec VPN (with PSK). I have forwarded UDP ports 1701, 500 and 4500 through the Mikrotik, and connections from outside work flawlessly. When I configure another Synology, this one at a client site, the exact same way, the port forwarding through the Telstra-supplied router just doesn't work. I have disabled the in-router VPN. The client says that the L2TP negotiation failed. Now here's the thing: Connecting to the VPN from inside the network works fine. So L2TP, IKE, IPsec-NAT-T, the pre-shared key and the NAS user credentials are all demonstrably correct. Attempt from outside the network and - nope. Not sure of the model of Telstra router (it's the black-faced vertical one with the big blue-lit button at top). Anyway, I have a couple of other Telstra routers, one a Netgear DEVG2020, on a Technicolor TG799vac. and as far as I can tell they don't work either! Is this a Telstra thing - don't let VPNs through? Is there a trick to it? Short of replacing the things with Mikrotiks, which I am seriously considering recommending... Regards, K. -- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~ Karl Auer (kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au) work +61 2 64957435 http://www.nullarbor.com.au mobile +61 428 957160 GPG fingerprint: CF68 0C56 EEE4 CC19 28D4 03B3 BCE0 E800 E31F 7254 Old fingerprint: 887A DA07 4DCC EE76 B413 27D4 C638 4189 6CF0 D556 _______________________________________________ Public mailing list Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com. au---------------------------- Roger Plant ------------------------------ Message: 6 Date: Fri, 16 Oct 2020 15:07:28 +1100 From: "Roger Plant" <rplant(a)melbpc.org.au> To: MikroTik Public <public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au>, kauer(a)nullarbor.com.au Subject: Re: [MT-AU Public] [OFF-TOPIC] Reverse question Message-ID: <5F891C80.12862.1420A81(a)rplant.melbpc.org.au> Content-Type: text/plain; charset=US-ASCII One other thought, Rebooting the Telstra Router after changing the port forwarding is sometimes required. ---------------------------- Roger Plant ------------------------------ Subject: Digest Footer _______________________________________________ Public mailing list Public(a)talk.mikrotik.com.au http://talk.mikrotik.com.au/mailman/listinfo/public_talk.mikrotik.com.au ------------------------------ End of Public Digest, Vol 79, Issue 1 *************************************

1 0